HUMAN DEVELOPMENT REPORT- 2009

Increasing mobility is not a new phenomenon. Theand more protectionist tendencies are the root
process which started slowly with the developmentscauses. Even a few developed countries are prone to
in the fields of science and technology graduallyprotectionist tendencies and intolerant towards the
evolved into lightning speed around the world. It hadimmigrants.
its repercussions both - good and bad. Alvin Toffler 
had conducted a detailed study on increasing mobilityNicholas Sarkozy, French President, was the Interior
and shared the information with the readers in hisMinister under the regime of Jacques Chirac, before
widely acclaimed book “The Future Shock”.becoming President. Sarkozy was a pain in the neck
 of Chirac for his xenophobic policies. Jacques Chirac
Increasing mobility and migration are interdependent.favoured Dominique De Villipine, the former Prime
No one is going to disagree with this truth.Minister according to the media reports to be his
Immigration- its positive and negative aspects- hassuccessor. Sarkozy could swing the mandate to his
become a subject for study and research at theside, for he adopted a more protectionist policy and
international level.it had many takers then. The infamous racist attacks,
 the widely condemned electrocution of two African
The other day there was a news item in ‘Theteenagers and his reported justification for the
Hindu’ by the noted journalist and correspondentsuppression of racist violence consequent upon it, his
Vidya Subramaniam on Human Development Reportsintolerance towards burqa-clad muslim women, even
(HDR) released simultaneously across the world bySikhs sporting turbans following their religious beliefs
Deputy Chairman, Planning Commission: Montek Singhduring that period and even after that, was widely
Ahluwalia and United Nations Co-ordinator Patricecondemned. Anyhow the highest position of
Coeur Bizot : Overcoming Barriers: Human mobility andPresident later somewhat made him show more
development and the salutary effects of migrationmaturity and he even played the role of a master
between countries- from developing countries todiplomat in arriving at an amicable solution to the war
developed countries, developing countries to otherbetween Russia and Georgia over South Ossetia,
developing countries and migration within countriesthus averting a catastrophe which would have
and the enormous potential, social, financial andreached an unimaginable dimension with USA
cultural brought about by the latter. The report isintervening under the belligerent George Bush, the
based on statistics and on going through it a citizenthen President. Xenophobia still stares in the face of
has much to feel cheerful about it. The report alsoimmigrants though. Economic recession across the
mentions about certain areas of a country which areworld has a damaging contribution to this nagging
left behind in the field of education resulting in theproblem.
reluctance of the inhabitants of these areas to 
emigrate to other parts of the country or to otherXenophobia and protectionist tendencies to a large
countries. A country like India, where lack ofextent are prevalent in various corners of the world.
adequate education facilities even 62 years afterNot only between countries but even in a particular
Independence has a lot to be ashamed of.country itself.
  
While feeling happy and elated about the positiveTake for example our own “Incredible
aspects migration brings about in the world, we feelNation”. The financial capital of India,
equally sad on going through news reports emanating“Mumbai” (sorry, not Bombay) is a glaring
from different countries on a regular basis - theexample of the “Sons of the soil”. The
harassment, hardships and torture the immigrantsemigrants from the States of UttarPradesh, Bihar,
suffer at the hands of the citizens of a particularOrissa always live in perpetual fear of the “policy
country. The “Sons of the soil” policy andholders”, the “Marathi mannoos”. About a
racist attacks escalate on a daily basis. Right belowyear ago, the North Indian inhabitants were brutally
the news report on emigration, with a feeling ofattacked, robbed of their belongings, their properties
sadness I came across a news item on the racistdestroyed and forced them to flee to their States.
attacks by Australians against the Indians who liveSome even succumbed to injuries on being badly
and lead peaceful lives working as cabbies,mauled. Poor men, women and children leaving their
bartendenders, such menial jobs and the students forbeloveds in their respective native States catch trains
the purpose of higher studies and dreaming of aand after three or four days of ardous train journeys
bright future. These attacks on Indians even afterreach the city not for leading a pompous life but for
government’s strong protests and despiteearning something to have atleast a square meal per
Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd’s assurancesday. They don’t stay in flats, bungalows or
to the Government of India on adopting a zerofive-star hotels but in slums, chawls and railway
tolerance towards the attackers continue unabated.platforms. Mumbai is nobody’s monopoly. It is a
Recently Juliet Gillard, the Education Minister ofpart of our nation and it should remain as such.
Australia on her visit to India also gave an assurance 
on these lines. All in vain. Now it is learnt that the1. I do not know whether the HDR (Human
Indian immigrants having lost their patience haveDevelopment Reports) took into account while
started to hit back in the same coin. As somebodypreparing it with the deserving significance. Anyhow
put it, “A confident resistance will make a thugas long as immigration remains a smooth affair and
flee”.mobility undisturbed, happy days are here to stay.
 Otherwise get doomed.
Xenophobia has become a bane across world. More